Nestled in the charming heart of Suffolk, NY, the tradition of High Tea is a delightful experience waiting to be savored.
Imagine a serene afternoon, where the clink of fine china and the aroma of freshly brewed tea blend with the laughter of good company.
Here, the timeless elegance of High Tea is served with a side of local warmth, inviting you to indulge in a spread of delicate pastries and savory treats.
Whether it’s a special occasion or a simple desire for a touch of luxury, High Tea in Suffolk is an enchanting escape into a world of refined relaxation and culinary delight.
1. The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe
Step into The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe and you’ll find yourself in a whimsical world reminiscent of an enchanted garden.
With its old-fashioned charm, this tearoom offers a cozy retreat where you can enjoy a leisurely afternoon.
The warm hospitality of the staff adds to the delightful experience, making it a perfect spot for creating cherished memories.
Begin your high tea adventure with their freshly baked scones, followed by an assortment of savory sandwiches and delicate puffs filled with a variety of flavors.
Don’t miss out on the dessert selection, especially the carrot cake that’s a crowd favorite.
For special occasions, the adorable mini birthday cake is a treat not only to the palate but also to the eyes.
2. Robinson’s Tea Room
Step into the quaint charm of Robinson’s Tea Room, where the blend of antique decor and a cozy ambiance invites you to a delightful high tea experience.
Indulge in a triple-tiered platter brimming with scrumptious scones, delicate finger sandwiches, and more.
The extensive tea selection, including the standout coconut cocoa tea, complements the hearty fare.
Don’t miss the chocolate-covered strawberries, a sweet finale to a fulfilling meal.
3. The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant
The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant is a charming escape into a world of delightful treats and serenity.
With its cozy atmosphere and warm hospitality, it’s the perfect spot for a relaxing afternoon.
Indulge in the two-tiered trays brimming with scrumptious baked goods, savory sandwiches, fresh fruit, and crisp salads.
Don’t miss out on their wide selection of teas to complete the quintessential high tea experience.
4. Tea House
Nestled in the heart of Deer Park, Tea House offers a serene escape with its cozy ambiance and a wide selection of aromatic teas.
Pair your tea with their delightful scones and clotted cream, or indulge in the assortment of petite sandwiches.
The pastries are a local favorite, especially the delicate macarons and the rich, buttery croissants.
5. SpecialTea House
SpecialTea House is a quaint retreat nestled in the heart of Greenport Village, offering a serene escape with its charming ambiance.
It’s the perfect spot for an intimate afternoon, where every detail from the decor to the service is curated to enhance your tea experience.
Indulge in the Classic Selection for a taste crafted with care, and don’t miss the exquisite
It’s a culinary journey that promises to transport you to the quaint cafes of Paris.
6. The Hidden Oak Café
Nestled in the Manor House of Bayard Cutting Arboretum, The Hidden Oak Café offers a tranquil retreat with its charming indoor and outdoor seating.
The café promises a friendly service within a relaxed atmosphere, perfect for unwinding after a stroll through the arboretum.
For a satisfying meal, the tuna sandwich and baked salmon come highly recommended, boasting generous portions at reasonable prices.
Pair your meal with a selection from their extensive tea menu, and don’t miss out on the delightful crumb and Kahlua cakes for dessert.
7. You, Me and Tea
Nestled in the heart of Port Jefferson, “You, Me and Tea” offers a cozy retreat for tea enthusiasts and novices alike.
With a knowledgeable owner who shares his rich heritage from a Turkish tea farm, visitors can embark on a flavorful journey through meticulously steeped teas that promise both comfort and discovery.
While sipping on your perfectly brewed cup, indulge in a selection of homemade treats that complement the tea experience.
From classic scones to an array of pastries, each bite is crafted to enhance the tea’s aroma and taste, ensuring a delightful pairing that will beckon you back for more.
8. Island Kava Patchogue
Island Kava Patchogue is a haven for creatives and professionals alike, offering a unique atmosphere where non-alcoholic beverages and mood-elevating teas spark inspiration and relaxation.
It’s the perfect blend of a workspace and a social hub, making it an essential visit for anyone seeking a refreshing change of pace.
Dive into a menu of exotic kava blends and soothing teas that promise to lift your spirits.
While the place focuses on drinks, the welcoming vibe and the chance to mingle with like-minded individuals are just as nourishing for the soul.
Don’t miss out on their signature brews that have become a staple for the regulars.
9. Toya’s Tea
Toya’s Tea offers a unique experience for tea enthusiasts with its weekend-only opening hours.
It’s the perfect getaway for those looking to indulge in a serene tea experience after a busy week.
The cozy ambiance and exclusive availability make it a sought-after destination for relaxation and social gatherings.
The menu boasts a variety of exquisite teas paired with delightful pastries and sandwiches.
Be sure to try their signature scones with clotted cream and jam, which perfectly complement their aromatic tea selections.
Whether you’re a tea connoisseur or a casual sipper, Toya’s Tea has something to tantalize everyone’s taste buds.
10. YAAAS TEA Huntington
With its daily availability from 11:30 AM to 8:00 PM, it’s the perfect spot for a refreshing pause any day of the week.
The staff, particularly Mauricio, are known for their exceptional service, making every visit feel personal and special.
Beyond the beverages, the desserts are equally impressive, offering a taste that’s simply out of this world.
11. Sweetwaters Coffee & Tea
Sweetwaters Coffee & Tea offers a serene oasis in Smithtown, perfect for a midday retreat.
The stylish ambiance paired with a diverse selection of teas makes it an ideal spot for tea enthusiasts and casual sippers alike.
The freshly baked scones and delicate finger sandwiches are crowd favorites, promising a truly authentic High Tea experience.
12. Cafe Lahooti
Cafe Lahooti stands out with its cozy ambiance and a delightful selection of teas that transport you straight to the valleys of Kashmir.
The seasonal Kashmir Pink Tea is a rare find, and the warmth of the service matches the comfort of their brews.
With non-dairy options available, everyone can indulge in a refreshing cup of their favorite tea.
13. Matcha Tea in Heaven
Nestled in the heart of Smithtown, “Matcha Tea in Heaven” offers a serene escape with its charming decor and an extensive selection of tea beverages.
It’s the perfect spot for tea enthusiasts looking to indulge in a luxurious experience, albeit at a premium price.
While the matcha milk tea stands out as a signature drink, the classic milk tea remains a solid choice for those seeking a traditional flavor.
Pair your tea with a selection of their less-appealing desserts for a complete high tea experience.
Just remember, the menu may not list prices, so inquire ahead to manage your budget.
14. Island Kava Tea House
Island Kava Tea House offers a unique experience with its warm and friendly staff ensuring excellent customer service.
It’s a place where the vibes are as varied as the tea selection, catering to those who appreciate a laid-back atmosphere with a touch of country charm.
While the tea selection is vast, the specialty drinks like the ‘Sunrise Special’ may intrigue the adventurous.
For a more traditional taste, the loose teas are a staple, though it’s recommended to inquire about milk alternatives to find your perfect match for a creamy delight.
15. Teal Kitchen & Cafe
Teal Kitchen & Cafe stands out with its all-day breakfast and diverse lunch menu, offering a cozy spot for a delightful high tea experience.
The friendly service and inviting atmosphere make it the perfect place for a relaxing break.
Don’t miss the customizable tater bowls and the avocado toast, which is a crowd favorite.
For a sweet treat, the churro bowls are a must-try, and the mango Tajin is a unique, flavorful delight that will leave you wanting more.
16. Victorian Room
The Victorian Room is a treasure trove of elegance and comfort, perfect for any special occasion.
With a team dedicated to exceeding expectations, every event becomes a cherished memory.
The ambiance exudes a classic charm that promises an experience of refined enjoyment.
Indulge in the culinary delights of the Victorian Room, where the food is as impressive as the service.
From savory sandwiches to sweet pastries, each bite is a testament to the venue’s commitment to quality.
The standout dishes are sure to tantalize your taste buds and leave you longing for more.
17. Clipper Ship Tea Company
With its immaculate presentation and knowledgeable staff, it’s a sanctuary where the love for tea is both understood and catered to.
Don’t miss out on their signature blends, which are not only a treat to the taste buds but also a testament to their commitment to quality and uniqueness.
17 Best High Tea in Suffolk, NY, United States for 2024
- The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe
- Robinson’s Tea Room
- The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant
- Tea House
- SpecialTea House
- The Hidden Oak Café
- You, Me and Tea
- Island Kava Patchogue
- Toya’s Tea
- YAAAS TEA Huntington
- Sweetwaters Coffee & Tea
- Cafe Lahooti
- Matcha Tea in Heaven
- Island Kava Tea House
- Teal Kitchen & Cafe
- Victorian Room
- Clipper Ship Tea Company
Many years ago, I, Henry Joseph, traded my corporate career for an apron and a bustling Tea Room in England’s Peak District. Now, in Mollymook, NSW, I continue to share my passion through AnniesHighTeas, offering personalized Grazing Boxes with local produce, inviting you to explore the world of high tea with me.
