Best High Tea in Long Island, NY: Top 20!

Imagine a serene afternoon on Long Island, where the charm of old-world elegance meets the comfort of modern luxury.

Here, the tradition of High Tea is celebrated with a delightful twist.

Picture yourself in a cozy nook, surrounded by the gentle clinking of fine china and the soft murmur of conversation.

The aroma of freshly brewed tea blends with the scent of buttery scones and delicate pastries.

This is High Tea in Long Island—a timeless ritual where every sip and bite invites you to savor the slower pace of life and indulge in the pleasure of good company.

Welcome to an experience that’s more than just tea—it’s a slice of tranquility in the bustling heart of New York.

1. Robinson’s Tea Room

Robinson's Tea Room

97E Main St, Stony Brook, NY 11790, USA
(631) 751-1232
View Menu
Open on Map

Step into Robinson’s Tea Room and you’re immediately enveloped in a warm, antique charm that promises a unique high tea experience.

It’s the perfect escape for a quaint afternoon, where the ritual of tea is celebrated with reverence and a touch of nostalgia.

Begin with the savory tier of finger sandwiches before indulging in freshly baked scones, clotted cream, and preserves.

The grand finale is a triple-tiered platter brimming with delights, but save room for their signature coconut cocoa tea and the decadent chocolate-covered strawberries that are a feast for both the eyes and the palate.

2. Tea House

Tea House

185 Bay Shore Rd, Deer Park, NY 11729, USA
(631) 940-7794
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of Deer Park, Tea House offers a serene escape with its cozy ambiance and a wide selection of aromatic teas.

Perfect for a midday retreat, the Tea House promises an experience that revitalizes the senses and calms the mind.

Pair your tea with their delightful scones and clotted cream, or indulge in the assortment of petite sandwiches.

Each bite is crafted to complement the tea’s rich flavors, ensuring a harmonious and satisfying high tea experience.

3. The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant

154 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point, NY 11715, USA
(631) 363-3100
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of Blue Point, The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant offers a cozy escape with its charming decor and tranquil ambiance.

It’s the perfect spot for a leisurely afternoon, where the warmth of hospitality matches the delightful array of teas.

Indulge in the two-tiered trays brimming with culinary delights: freshly baked goods, savory sandwiches, ripe fruit, and crisp salads.

4. The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe

The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe

225 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USA
(631) 476-8327
View Menu
Open on Map

Step into the charming world of The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe, where the ambiance of an old-fashioned tea room creates a delightful retreat from the hustle and bustle.

Owned by a warm family duo, this quaint spot in Port Jefferson is a gem for those seeking a cozy atmosphere for special occasions or a leisurely afternoon.

Indulge in their signature soft and buttery scones that stand out even without the traditional clotted cream and jam.

With a vast selection of teas to choose from, each visit becomes a unique experience.

Remember, the afternoon tea tower is a treat just for you, so savor the moment at this beloved Suffolk County haven.

5. The Hidden Oak Café

The Hidden Oak Café

440 Montauk Hwy, Great River, NY 11739, USA
(631) 277-3895
View Menu
Open on Map

Nestled in the historic Manor House of Bayard Cutting Arboretum, The Hidden Oak Café offers a tranquil retreat with its charming indoor and outdoor seating.

With a friendly staff and a serene view of the lawn and river, it’s the perfect spot for a relaxing high tea experience.

Savor the flavors of their delicious tuna sandwich and perfectly cooked baked salmon, or indulge in a variety of teas from their extensive selection.

While some desserts may miss the mark, the crumb and Kahlua cakes are local favorites.

6. Island Kava Tea House

Island Kava Tea House

4217 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758, USA
(516) 795-0945
View Menu
Open on Map

Island Kava Tea House offers a unique experience with its warm and friendly staff, ensuring every visit is met with excellent customer service.

The cozy atmosphere, coupled with the diverse selection of kava and tea, makes it a perfect spot for relaxation and social gatherings.

While the tea selection is vast, the specialty drinks like the ‘Sunrise Special’ are a hit.

For those seeking a non-dairy alternative, the oat milk option provides a creamy texture to their lattes, albeit with a unique taste profile that may not suit all palates.

7. SpecialTea House

SpecialTea House

455 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA
(631) 477-2265
View Menu
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of Greenport Village, SpecialTea House offers an enchanting retreat reminiscent of a Parisian afternoon tea.

With its limited opening days, it ensures exclusivity and a fresh experience for every visitor.

Indulge in the Classic Selection for a taste crafted with care, and don’t miss the signature Rose Tea Latte, adorned with delicate rose petals.

The beautiful tea set complements the exquisite interior, making every meal a memorable event.

8. You, Me and Tea

You, Me and Tea

45 Chandler Sq, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USA
(631) 828-5558
View Menu
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of Port Jefferson, “You, Me and Tea” is a cozy retreat for tea enthusiasts and novices alike.

The owner’s personal journey from a tea farm in Turkey to this charming store brings authenticity and a wealth of knowledge to your tea-tasting adventure.

Indulge in a diverse selection of leaf teas, each with its unique flavor profile, expertly steeped to perfection.

Complement your cup with an array of delightful treats and savor the comfort of their delicious blends in a selection of beautifully crafted tea mugs, cups, and pots.

9. M Tea

M Tea

23-01 41st Ave Store 1D, Queens, NY 11101, USA
(315) 889-3222
View Menu
Open on Map

M Tea is a delightful retreat in Queens, NY, offering a fresh take on the traditional high tea experience.

With its cozy ambiance and a selection of 100% fresh fruit drinks and famous brown sugar bubble tea, it’s the perfect spot for a relaxing afternoon.

Indulge in M Tea’s unique desserts, like their rich mousse cakes with a light jelly texture, or enjoy the soft boba paired with flavorful tea.

The diverse menu ensures there’s something for every palate, including milk alternatives for the drinks.

10. Prince Tea House

Prince Tea House

15 Station Square, Queens, NY 11375, USA
(718) 971-1088
View Menu
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of Queens, Prince Tea House offers a tranquil retreat with its cozy ambiance and exceptional service.

It’s the perfect place to unwind with a cup of customizable milk tea and delightful appetizers.

Don’t miss out on the solid selection of appetizers that pair wonderfully with their signature milk teas.

The ability to adjust the sugar level to your taste makes each sip a personalized experience.

11. Prince Tea House

Prince Tea House

36-39 Prince St, Queens, NY 11354, USA
(917) 285-2523
View Menu
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of Queens, Prince Tea House offers a cozy retreat with its charming decor and an extensive selection of aromatic French teas.

Indulge in the delightful array of desserts, from the light and airy macarons to the rich and decadent chocolate gateau.

Pair your sweet treat with a pot of their signature tea for a quintessential high tea experience.

12. YAAAS TEA Farmingdale

YAAAS TEA Farmingdale

118 Secatogue Ave, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA
(516) 454-8888
View Menu
Open on Map

YAAAS TEA Farmingdale is a charming spot that promises a warm welcome and a delightful experience.

The staff’s dedication to service shines through, ensuring every visit is memorable.

Indulge in the light and fluffy cakes, with flavors like Strawberry and Mango, each a sweet testament to daily freshness.

For a unique sip, try the warm and chewy boba that sets a new standard for bubble tea lovers.

The Matcha Latte and Iced Green Tea with Passionfruit are just a couple of the refreshing beverages that await you.

13. Chat Noir

Chat Noir

230 Merrick Rd, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA
(516) 208-8521
View Menu
Open on Map

Chat Noir offers a quintessential high tea experience with its charming ambiance and friendly service.

It’s the perfect spot for special occasions, from bridal showers to a leisurely afternoon with friends.

The variety of teas and the aroma of delicious meals set the stage for a memorable visit.

Indulge in the tea service, which includes an assortment of finely crafted sandwiches and pastries.

The calamari is a crowd-pleaser, and the extensive menu promises something for every palate.

Remember to reserve your spot to minimize wait time and enjoy a delightful culinary journey at Chat Noir.

14. Lady Mendl’s Tea Salon

Lady Mendl's Tea Salon

56 Irving Pl, New York, NY 10003, USA
(212) 533-4600
View Menu
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of New York, Lady Mendl’s Tea Salon offers a serene retreat with its Victorian charm and attentive service.

It’s the perfect spot for those seeking a luxurious escape from the city’s frenzy.

Indulge in the delightful scones and the zesty lemon sponge cake, which are the highlights of their menu.

For tea lovers, choosing a single flavor to savor throughout your visit might enhance your experience amidst the sweet indulgences.

15. Alice’s Tea Cup, Chapter 2

Alice's Tea Cup, Chapter 2

156 E 64th St, New York, NY 10065, USA
(212) 486-9200
View Menu
Open on Map

Step into the enchanting world of Alice’s Tea Cup, Chapter 2, where the whimsy of a fairytale meets the comfort of your favorite café.

With its vibrant décor and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, it’s the perfect escape from the bustling streets of New York.

Indulge in the delightful ‘Mad Hatter’ tea service or savor the rich flavors of their smoked salmon and two-egg sandwiches.

Don’t miss out on their famous scones, a treat so delightful, you’ll find yourself coming back for more.

16. YAAAS TEA Huntington

YAAAS TEA Huntington

347 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743, USA
(631) 271-7777
View Menu
Open on Map

YAAAS TEA Huntington is a bubble tea paradise where the boba pearls are always springy and the flavors burst with freshness.

It’s a cozy spot that’s become a weekly ritual for many, thanks to the exceptional service from staff like Mauricio and Juan, who make every visit feel personal.

Whether you’re in for a classic milk tea or adventurous with your taste buds, YAAAS TEA ensures a delightful experience with every sip and bite.

17. Prince Tea House East Village

Prince Tea House East Village

204 E 10th St, New York, NY 10003, USA
(917) 388-2778
View Menu
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of East Village, Prince Tea House offers a tranquil escape with its Asian-European fusion delights.

The ambiance exudes comfort, complemented by friendly service that makes you feel right at home.

With teas sourced from the lush fields of France, each sip promises a journey of refined flavors.

Pair it with the vibrant Fruit Toast, a symphony of fresh fruits atop a golden-brown toast.

For a savory twist, the Smoked Salmon is a must, adding a touch of elegance to your high tea experience.

Don’t miss the Trio Combo for a taste of everything that makes this place special.

18. Island Kava Patchogue

Island Kava Patchogue

73 N Ocean Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772, USA
(631) 627-8520
View Menu
Open on Map

Island Kava Patchogue is a haven for creatives and professionals alike, offering a unique atmosphere where non-alcoholic beverages and mood-elevating teas spark inspiration.

The welcoming vibe, fostered by the friendly staff, makes it an ideal spot for both work and leisure.

While sipping on their signature kava or kratom tea, indulge in a selection of herbal infusions and snacks.

The menu may not be extensive, but the quality and care put into each offering make each visit a delightful experience.

19. Teazzi Tea Shop

Teazzi Tea Shop

43-21 Hunter St, Queens, NY 11101, USA
(347) 554-2680
View Menu
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of Queens, Teazzi Tea Shop offers a unique twist on the traditional high tea experience.

With its modern approach to tea-making and a cozy atmosphere, it’s a charming spot for tea enthusiasts and casual sippers alike.

While the house special tea, complete with oats, is a bold choice, the boba stands out as a chewy delight.

Despite some service hiccups, Teazzi’s innovative offerings make it a noteworthy visit.

20. Shari’s Tea

Shari's Tea

28-07 Jackson Ave 11th Floor, Queens, NY 11101, USA
View Menu
Open on Map

Shari’s Tea offers a luxurious escape into the world of tea with its custom blends and unique tea kits.

The expertise and passion for tea are evident in every sip, making it a haven for tea enthusiasts.

Pair your tea with their signature beet tea or create your own blend for a personalized experience.

The tea tasting events are a delight, offering a chance to savor various distinct teas and learn the art of brewing.

20 Best High Tea in Long Island, NY, United States for 2024

  • Robinson’s Tea Room
  • Tea House
  • The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant
  • The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe
  • The Hidden Oak Café
  • Island Kava Tea House
  • SpecialTea House
  • You, Me and Tea
  • M Tea
  • Prince Tea House
  • Prince Tea House
  • YAAAS TEA Farmingdale
  • Chat Noir
  • Lady Mendl’s Tea Salon
  • Alice’s Tea Cup, Chapter 2
  • YAAAS TEA Huntington
  • Prince Tea House East Village
  • Island Kava Patchogue
  • Teazzi Tea Shop
  • Shari’s Tea