Best High Tea in Cape May, NJ: Top 19!

Nestled along the picturesque shores of New Jersey, the charming coastal town of Cape May beckons visitors with its historic Victorian architecture, idyllic beaches, and an enchanting ambiance that captures the essence of a bygone era. Amidst this quaint seaside haven, the tradition of indulging in a delightful afternoon pastime awaits – High Tea. Step into a world of elegance and refinement as you partake in this cherished ritual, where delicate china, delectable treats, and perfectly steeped tea create a symphony of flavors and experiences. Whether seeking a respite from the sun-drenched shores or simply desiring a touch of sophistication, a High Tea experience in Cape May promises a journey into a realm of timeless charm and culinary delight.

1. Tea By the Sea

405 W Perry St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 898-4832
Visit Website
Open on Map

Tea By the Sea is a delightful tea shop located at 405 W Perry St in the charming coastal town of Cape May, NJ. As a tea enthusiast, I recently had the pleasure of experiencing their High Tea service, and I must say, it was an absolute delight.

Nestled in a picturesque location, Tea By the Sea offers a serene and inviting atmosphere. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the enchanting aroma of various tea blends. The shop itself is beautifully decorated, with shelves adorned with an extensive collection of loose teas, fine china, and charming children’s tea sets.

The High Tea experience at Tea By the Sea is truly a treat for the senses. The service was impeccable, with the staff being attentive and knowledgeable about their tea offerings. The tea menu was extensive, featuring an impressive selection of black, green, white, and herbal teas from around the world. I was thrilled to see such a wide variety to choose from.

The tea was served in elegant china teapots and accompanied by an assortment of delicate finger sandwiches, scones with clotted cream and jam, and an array of delectable pastries. Each item was exquisitely presented, showcasing the artistry and attention to detail that goes into creating a memorable High Tea experience.

The teas themselves were of exceptional quality, bursting with flavor and aroma. Whether it was a robust Earl Grey or a refreshing herbal infusion, each cup was brewed to perfection, allowing the flavors to shine through. The staff was more than happy to offer recommendations and share their knowledge about the different teas, making the experience both enjoyable and educational.

What sets Tea By the Sea apart is their commitment to providing a comprehensive tea experience. In addition to the High Tea service, they offer a wide range of loose teas for purchase, ensuring that you can continue enjoying your favorite blends at home. The selection of fine china and tea accessories is also impressive, catering to tea lovers of all ages and tastes.

Overall, my experience at Tea By the Sea was truly enchanting. The combination of impeccable service, a vast tea selection, and delectable treats made for an unforgettable High Tea experience. Whether you’re a tea aficionado or simply looking for a unique and enjoyable outing, I highly recommend Tea By the Sea. It’s a hidden gem in Cape May that will transport you to a world of tea-infused bliss.

2. The Harrison

613 Columbia Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-4948
Visit Website
Open on Map

Nestled on 613 Columbia Ave in the picturesque town of Cape May, The Harrison exudes an air of elegance and charm. This exquisite 1867 B&B, with its inviting wraparound porch, beckons guests to step back in time and indulge in a delightful high tea experience.

Upon entering The Harrison, one is immediately transported to a bygone era, where attention to detail and period-inspired aesthetics reign supreme. The ambiance is nothing short of enchanting, with antique furnishings and tasteful decor that pay homage to the inn’s rich history.

The high tea service at The Harrison is a true treat for the senses. The moment one settles into their seat, a delightful assortment of delicate teacups, saucers, and silverware awaits, promising an experience steeped in sophistication. The attentive staff, clad in traditional attire, adds to the old-world charm and ensures that every guest feels like a cherished visitor.

The selection of teas at The Harrison is nothing short of impressive. From classic English Breakfast to aromatic herbal blends, the choices cater to every palate. The teas are flawlessly brewed and served piping hot, allowing the flavors to unfold with each sip. For those seeking a twist on tradition, The Harrison also offers a range of exotic teas, adding an element of adventure to the experience.

Now, onto the pièce de résistance—the delectable array of treats that accompany the tea. The Harrison pulls out all the stops, presenting an assortment of dainty finger sandwiches filled with savory delights. From cucumber and cream cheese to smoked salmon and dill, each bite is a delightful marriage of flavors and textures. The scones, a quintessential component of any high tea, are nothing short of perfection—fluffy, buttery, and served with clotted cream and preserves.

The delectable journey continues with a selection of petite pastries and cakes that are as pleasing to the eye as they are to the palate. From delicate macarons to rich chocolate truffles, these delectable delights showcase the culinary artistry of The Harrison’s talented pastry chefs. The sheer variety and attention to detail make it evident that no expense is spared in creating a truly memorable high tea experience.

As one savors each bite and sip, the elegant atmosphere of The Harrison creates an ambiance of relaxation and refinement. The wraparound porch offers a serene setting, allowing guests to soak in the charm of Cape May while enjoying their tea. Whether it’s a leisurely afternoon with friends or a special celebration, The Harrison provides the perfect backdrop for an unforgettable high tea experience.

In conclusion, The Harrison in Cape May, NJ, is a hidden gem that transports guests to a bygone era of grace and refinement. With its elegant ambiance, attentive staff, and an impeccable selection of teas and delectable treats, it offers a high tea experience that is truly extraordinary. If you find yourself in Cape May, a visit to The Harrison is an absolute must for tea aficionados and lovers of all things elegant.

3. Art Block Cafe

507 Washington St #108, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(917) 536-2047
Visit Website
Open on Map

Nestled in the heart of Cape May, New Jersey, Art Block Cafe stands as a unique shop and studio that offers a delightful high tea experience. Located at 507 Washington St #108, this charming café captures the essence of Cape May’s vibrant atmosphere while providing a haven for tea enthusiasts.

Upon entering Art Block Cafe, visitors are greeted by an inviting ambiance that combines artistic charm with a cozy setting. The café’s tasteful décor, adorned with captivating artwork, creates an immersive and visually appealing experience. The warm and friendly staff add to the welcoming atmosphere, making guests feel right at home.

One of the highlights of Art Block Cafe is its high tea service, which promises a delightful journey for the taste buds. The carefully curated selection of teas offers a range of flavors, catering to both traditional and adventurous palates. From classic black teas to refreshing herbal blends, tea connoisseurs are sure to find their perfect cup.

The presentation of the high tea is a feast for the eyes. The delicate porcelain teaware, accompanied by exquisite tiered trays adorned with an assortment of delectable treats, adds an elegant touch to the experience. Indulge in freshly baked scones, accompanied by clotted cream and homemade preserves, as you sip on your choice of tea. Delight in the array of finger sandwiches, featuring a variety of fillings, all crafted with attention to detail and flavors that complement each other.

Art Block Cafe’s high tea experience also extends to its delectable pastries and desserts. From delicate macarons to miniature tarts bursting with flavor, each bite is a delightful surprise. The skilled pastry chefs have truly mastered the art of balancing taste and aesthetics.

What sets Art Block Cafe apart from other tea houses is the seamless integration of art and tea. As you indulge in the delicious offerings, you can immerse yourself in the vibrant art studio that surrounds you. Admire the works of talented local artists, whose creations adorn the walls, creating a unique and inspiring backdrop for your tea experience.

The café’s commitment to quality extends beyond its culinary offerings. The attentive and knowledgeable staff are more than happy to guide guests through the menu and provide recommendations based on individual preferences. Their genuine passion for tea and art shines through, elevating the overall experience.

In summary, Art Block Cafe in Cape May, New Jersey, is a hidden gem that combines the love for tea and art. With its inviting atmosphere, delectable treats, and a seamless integration of art into the café, this charming establishment offers a memorable high tea experience. Whether you’re a tea aficionado or simply seeking a delightful afternoon in a unique setting, Art Block Cafe is sure to captivate your senses and leave you with a lasting impression.

4. Angel of the Sea

5 Trenton Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-3369
Visit Website
Open on Map

Located at 5 Trenton Ave, Cape May, New Jersey, Angel of the Sea offers a charming setting on a 19th-century property. Alongside its cozy accommodations, this establishment provides a complimentary breakfast and afternoon tea service for its guests to enjoy. I recently had the pleasure of experiencing their afternoon high tea, and I must say, it was a delightful affair.

The moment I entered Angel of the Sea, I was captivated by the historical ambiance and elegant decor. The high ceilings, vintage furnishings, and tasteful details transported me to a bygone era. The dedicated tea area was beautifully arranged, with pristine table settings and delicate floral arrangements that added a touch of sophistication.

The staff at Angel of the Sea were attentive and friendly throughout my high tea experience. They were knowledgeable about the tea selection and happily provided recommendations based on personal preferences. Their professionalism and warm hospitality contributed to a relaxed and enjoyable atmosphere.

The highlight of the afternoon tea was undoubtedly the delectable assortment of treats. From classic scones to dainty finger sandwiches and an array of sweet pastries, each bite was a delightful surprise. The presentation was impeccable, with colorful and visually appealing creations that showcased the skill and creativity of the pastry chefs.

The tea selection offered a wide variety of flavors to suit different palates. Whether one prefers the robustness of black tea or the fragrant notes of herbal infusions, there was something to please everyone. The tea was served piping hot and the quality was evident with each sip, enhancing the overall experience.

Angel of the Sea’s afternoon high tea is truly a delightful experience. Whether you are a guest at the inn or a visitor to Cape May, this is a must-try for tea enthusiasts and those looking for a charming and relaxing afternoon activity. The combination of the historic setting, impeccable service, and mouthwatering treats creates a memorable experience that lingers long after the last sip of tea.

In conclusion, Angel of the Sea’s high tea service exceeded my expectations. The quaint surroundings, impeccable service, and delectable treats make it a standout choice for anyone seeking a memorable afternoon tea experience. I highly recommend it to tea lovers and those who appreciate the finer things in life.

5. Jardin At The Hugh

653 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 435-5458
Visit Website
Open on Map

Located at 653 Washington St in Cape May, New Jersey, Jardin At The Hugh is a delightful destination for a high tea experience. This eco-friendly and plant-forward restaurant offers a French-inspired cuisine that showcases the best of local, organic, and seasonal produce. With its commitment to vegetarian and vegan-friendly options, Jardin truly caters to a diverse range of dietary preferences.

Stepping into Jardin, guests are immediately greeted by an inviting and elegant atmosphere. The decor is tastefully done, combining modern elements with a touch of classic charm. The ambiance sets the stage for a serene and relaxing high tea experience.

The prix-fixe menu at Jardin is a true testament to the restaurant’s dedication to quality and sustainability. Each item is carefully crafted to highlight the flavors and textures of the ingredients used. The selection of teas is extensive, offering a variety of aromatic blends that complement the food perfectly.

As a vegetarian, I was thrilled to find such a diverse range of options available. The finger sandwiches, scones, and pastries served during the high tea were all beautifully presented and packed with delicious flavors. The attention to detail in both taste and presentation was evident in every bite.

One of the standout aspects of Jardin At The Hugh is their commitment to using local and organic ingredients. This not only enhances the taste and freshness of the food but also supports the local community and promotes sustainable farming practices. It’s a commendable initiative that adds an extra layer of appreciation to the dining experience.

The service at Jardin was top-notch, with attentive and knowledgeable staff members who were eager to ensure a memorable high tea experience. They were well-informed about the menu, accommodating special requests, and providing insightful recommendations. The staff’s warm and friendly demeanor further enhanced the overall enjoyment of the visit.

The location of Jardin At The Hugh adds to its allure. Situated in the beautiful Cape May, the restaurant offers a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Whether you choose to dine indoors or in their charming outdoor seating area, you are treated to picturesque surroundings that complement the culinary experience.

In conclusion, Jardin At The Hugh in Cape May, New Jersey, is a hidden gem that truly stands out for its eco-friendly approach, plant-forward cuisine, and commitment to quality. With a delectable prix-fixe menu featuring local and organic ingredients, vegetarian and vegan-friendly options, and impeccable service, it’s no wonder this restaurant has garnered recognition as the best dining spot at the Shore. If you’re in the area and looking for a memorable high tea experience, Jardin is a must-visit destination that won’t disappoint.

6. Coffee Tyme At The Beach

315 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 435-5647
Visit Website
Open on Map

Coffee Tyme At The Beach, located at 315 Beach Ave in Cape May, NJ 08204, USA, is a charming counter-serve café that offers a delightful selection of hot and iced coffee, along with an assortment of baked goods and breakfast sandwiches.

Upon entering Coffee Tyme At The Beach, I was immediately captivated by its cozy and inviting ambiance. The rustic décor, combined with the warm and friendly atmosphere, created the perfect setting for a relaxing high tea experience.

The menu at Coffee Tyme At The Beach features an array of coffee options, catering to both traditionalists and adventurous palates. Whether you prefer a classic cup of steaming hot coffee or a refreshing iced version, this café has something for everyone. The quality of the coffee was exceptional, with each sip offering a rich and robust flavor that truly satisfied my caffeine cravings.

In addition to their stellar coffee selection, Coffee Tyme At The Beach boasts a delectable assortment of baked goods. From flaky croissants to moist muffins, the display case was a feast for the eyes. The pastries were freshly baked, exuding a tantalizing aroma that drew me in. Each bite was a pure delight, with the pastries delivering on both taste and texture.

The café also offers a variety of breakfast sandwiches, which proved to be a fantastic accompaniment to my high tea experience. The sandwiches were made to order with fresh ingredients, resulting in a harmonious blend of flavors. Whether you prefer a classic bacon and egg combination or a vegetarian option, the menu provided ample choices to suit different dietary preferences.

The staff at Coffee Tyme At The Beach deserves special mention for their exceptional service. They were attentive, courteous, and knowledgeable, making me feel welcomed and well taken care of throughout my visit. Their genuine passion for coffee and dedication to providing an enjoyable customer experience truly elevated my high tea experience.

Overall, Coffee Tyme At The Beach exceeded my expectations with its quaint charm, quality coffee, delicious baked goods, and excellent service. Whether you’re seeking a quick caffeine fix or a leisurely high tea experience, this café is definitely worth a visit. I highly recommend stopping by if you find yourself in Cape May, NJ.

7. Magic Brain Cafe

31 Perry St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
Visit Website
Open on Map

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Magic Brain Cafe located at 31 Perry St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA, and I must say it was a delightful experience. As soon as I stepped into the cafe, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The interior was beautifully designed with a casual and cozy ambiance, featuring charming wood-clad walls that added a rustic touch to the space.

Magic Brain Cafe is primarily known for its excellent coffee, but I was pleasantly surprised to find out that they also offered a fantastic high tea experience. The selection of teas available was impressive, catering to various preferences and tastes. Whether you’re a fan of classic black tea, fragrant herbal blends, or unique flavored options, there was something for everyone.

The high tea service at Magic Brain Cafe was a true treat. Served on elegant tiered trays, the assortment of sweets and baked goods was simply mouthwatering. From delicate finger sandwiches filled with savory goodness to freshly baked scones served with clotted cream and jam, each bite was a perfect balance of flavors and textures. The pastries were also a delight, with their flaky crusts and decadent fillings that melted in my mouth.

What truly stood out during my visit was the impeccable service provided by the friendly and attentive staff. They were knowledgeable about the tea selection and happy to assist with any questions or recommendations. Their passion for creating a memorable experience was evident in their genuine enthusiasm and willingness to ensure that every guest was satisfied.

In addition to the delectable treats and top-notch service, the pricing at Magic Brain Cafe was reasonable and offered good value for the quality of the high tea experience. Whether you’re looking to celebrate a special occasion or simply indulge in an afternoon of relaxation, this cafe is definitely worth a visit.

Overall, my experience at Magic Brain Cafe exceeded my expectations. The combination of a charming atmosphere, delectable treats, a wide tea selection, and attentive service made it an exceptional high tea destination. I highly recommend visiting this cafe for a delightful and memorable tea experience in Cape May, NJ.

8. Coffee Tyme At The Mall

414 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 435-5647
Visit Website
Open on Map

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Coffee Tyme At The Mall located at 414 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA, and I must say, it lived up to its reputation as the #1 Coffee Shop in Cape May on TripAdvisor. This charming establishment has been consistently recognized for its excellence, having been voted the Best Coffee of Cape May in 2015, 2016, 2017, and 2018.

Walking into Coffee Tyme At The Mall, I was immediately greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The cozy interior, coupled with the delightful aroma of freshly brewed coffee, created a perfect setting for a relaxing high tea experience. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that every customer felt welcome and well taken care of.

As I perused their extensive menu, I was delighted to find an impressive selection of freshly made baked goods and mouthwatering breakfast sandwiches. This added variety made Coffee Tyme At The Mall an ideal destination for those seeking more than just a cup of coffee. I was particularly drawn to their delectable assortment of pastries, which were not only visually appealing but also packed with flavor.

The highlight of my visit was undoubtedly the high tea service. The attention to detail was evident from the moment the elegantly arranged tea set was placed before me. The selection of teas was extensive, ranging from classic black teas to fragrant herbal blends. Each cup was brewed to perfection, allowing me to savor the rich and nuanced flavors.

Accompanying the tea were an array of delectable treats, including dainty finger sandwiches, scones with clotted cream and jam, and an assortment of delicate pastries. The sandwiches were filled with fresh and flavorful ingredients, providing a delightful balance of textures and tastes. The scones, with their golden crusts and soft interiors, were the epitome of perfection. And the pastries, with their exquisite craftsmanship, were a true feast for the eyes and the palate.

The service throughout the high tea experience was impeccable. The staff was knowledgeable and passionate about tea, happily answering any questions I had and making recommendations based on my preferences. They ensured that my teapot was always filled, and each course was presented with care and precision.

Overall, my experience at Coffee Tyme At The Mall was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment I stepped in until the moment I left, I was treated to outstanding service, a delightful ambiance, and a high tea experience that exceeded my expectations. Whether you’re a coffee aficionado, a lover of baked goods, or simply someone looking for a memorable high tea experience, I highly recommend paying a visit to Coffee Tyme At The Mall.

9. The Queen Victoria

102 Ocean St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-8702
Visit Website
Open on Map

Nestled on Ocean Street in Cape May, New Jersey, The Queen Victoria is a delightful old-world bed and breakfast that exudes elegance and charm. This hidden gem, comprising of a collection of quaint houses dating back to 1876, offers a truly enchanting experience for those seeking a memorable afternoon tea.

Upon entering The Queen Victoria, guests are greeted by the warm and inviting atmosphere that permeates throughout the establishment. The staff members, dressed in traditional attire, extend a gracious welcome, immediately setting the tone for a refined and sophisticated experience.

The highlight of any visit to The Queen Victoria is undoubtedly their afternoon tea service. This beloved tradition is beautifully executed, showcasing a selection of delectable treats and fine teas. As you settle into one of the meticulously furnished porches, the attentive staff will guide you through the array of mouthwatering options.

The selection of teas is extensive, catering to a variety of tastes. From classic Earl Grey and English Breakfast to exotic blends such as jasmine green tea and fragrant herbal infusions, there is something to please every palate. Each cup is brewed to perfection, allowing the flavors to fully blossom and transport you to a state of relaxation.

Accompanying the tea are an assortment of finger sandwiches, scones, and pastries that are both visually appealing and scrumptious. The sandwiches, neatly arranged on a tiered tray, offer a range of flavors, from classic cucumber and smoked salmon to inventive combinations like cranberry chicken and brie. The scones, served warm and accompanied by clotted cream and jam, are flaky, buttery delights that melt in your mouth. The pastries, with their delicate presentation and exquisite flavors, provide a sweet ending to the experience.

What sets The Queen Victoria apart is the attention to detail and the genuine hospitality of the staff. They go above and beyond to ensure that every guest feels welcomed and pampered. The ambiance of the B&B itself adds to the charm, with its antique furnishings, elegant decor, and serene atmosphere.

While the Queen Victoria does not offer an extensive menu beyond their afternoon tea service, this is by design, allowing them to focus on delivering an exceptional experience. It is a place where you can step back in time, indulge in delectable treats, and revel in the art of conversation while sipping on a fragrant cup of tea.

For those seeking a respite from the hustle and bustle of modern life, The Queen Victoria is a haven of tranquility. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking to unwind, their high tea service is an experience to be savored. With its charming ambiance, attentive service, and delightful selection of teas and treats, The Queen Victoria is a hidden gem that captures the essence of old-world elegance.

10. Tommy’s Folly

200 Congress Pl, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-6566
Visit Website
Open on Map

I recently had the pleasure of experiencing a delightful high tea at Tommy’s Folly, located at 200 Congress Pl, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA. Nestled within the charming Congress Hall, this gem of a place offers not only a General Store and Boutique but also a cozy Coffeeshop that serves a remarkable high tea experience.

As soon as I stepped into Tommy’s Folly, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The interior exudes a classic charm with its tasteful decor, combining vintage elements with a touch of modern elegance. The cozy seating arrangements, adorned with plush cushions, created an ambiance perfect for enjoying a leisurely afternoon tea.

The high tea menu at Tommy’s Folly was truly a treat for the senses. The selection of teas available was impressive, ranging from traditional blends to unique and aromatic varieties. Each cup was carefully brewed to perfection, delivering a rich and flavorful experience with every sip. The knowledgeable staff was attentive and provided helpful recommendations, ensuring that every guest’s preferences were catered to.

Accompanying the tea were the delectable treats that adorned the tiered stand before me. From delicate finger sandwiches to freshly baked scones, the selection was both enticing and satisfying. The sandwiches were beautifully crafted, offering a medley of flavors and textures. The scones, served warm, were delightfully crumbly on the outside and soft on the inside, paired perfectly with clotted cream and homemade jams. The assortment of pastries and sweets provided a delightful finale to the experience, with each bite being a heavenly combination of flavors and a visual delight.

Apart from the culinary delights, the service at Tommy’s Folly was exemplary. The staff was attentive, friendly, and well-versed in the art of high tea. They ensured that every guest’s needs were met, offering prompt service while maintaining a relaxed and unhurried pace. The attention to detail and genuine care for the guests’ experience added an extra layer of enjoyment to the overall ambiance.

One cannot overlook the convenience of Tommy’s Folly being located within Congress Hall. After indulging in the high tea experience, guests have the opportunity to explore the General Store and Boutique, which is filled with beautiful Cape Resorts merchandise. It’s an excellent way to browse through a curated selection of local treasures and souvenirs, making the visit to Tommy’s Folly an all-encompassing experience.

Overall, my high tea experience at Tommy’s Folly was nothing short of exceptional. The combination of delightful teas, delectable treats, and attentive service in the charming setting of Cape May created an afternoon of pure bliss. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, I highly recommend indulging in the high tea experience at Tommy’s Folly for an unforgettable and quintessentially Cape May experience.

11. Magnolia Room

301 Howard St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-8409
Visit Website
Open on Map

I recently had the pleasure of experiencing high tea at the Magnolia Room, located at 301 Howard St in Cape May, NJ. This charming establishment offers a seasonal selection of Southern classics, ranging from delectable fried chicken to mouthwatering crab cakes. Nestled within an elegant and historic space, the Magnolia Room provides a delightful setting for an afternoon of indulgence.

As I entered the Magnolia Room, I was immediately captivated by its old-world charm. The historic ambiance, with its tastefully adorned walls and classic furnishings, created an atmosphere that transported me to a bygone era. The attention to detail in the decor truly added to the overall experience.

The high tea menu at Magnolia Room is a celebration of Southern cuisine at its finest. The seasonal options provided a delightful variety of flavors and textures, showcasing the culinary expertise of the kitchen. The fried chicken was a true highlight, boasting a perfectly crispy exterior and tender, juicy meat. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, and it was evident that great care had been taken in preparing this classic dish.

Another standout on the menu was the crab cakes. These golden delights were packed with succulent crab meat and complemented with just the right amount of seasoning. The cakes were expertly cooked to a golden brown, offering a satisfying crunch with each bite. Paired with a tangy sauce, they provided a delightful contrast of flavors.

The service at the Magnolia Room was impeccable. The staff members were attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about their craft. From the moment I entered to the moment I left, I felt well taken care of and pampered. The staff’s attention to detail and their commitment to providing a memorable experience truly set the Magnolia Room apart.

In conclusion, the Magnolia Room in Cape May, NJ, is a hidden gem that offers a delightful high tea experience. Its elegant and historic setting, combined with the seasonal selection of Southern classics, makes it a must-visit for food enthusiasts and those looking to indulge in a taste of the South. Whether you’re craving mouthwatering fried chicken or delectable crab cakes, the Magnolia Room is sure to satisfy your cravings. Prepare to be transported to a bygone era as you savor the flavors and immerse yourself in the charm of this exquisite establishment.

12. Out There Coffee

315 Ocean St, Washington St UNIT 22, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
Visit Website
Open on Map

Out There Coffee, located at 315 Ocean St, Washington St UNIT 22, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA, is a charming café that not only excels in serving locally roasted coffee and espresso but also offers a delightful High Tea experience. Stepping into this cozy establishment, I was immediately captivated by the warm and inviting atmosphere that permeates throughout.

The High Tea at Out There Coffee is a true testament to their dedication to providing carefully crafted drinks and delicious treats. The tea selection is extensive, featuring an array of flavors that cater to all palates. From classic black teas to fragrant herbal blends, there is something for everyone to enjoy. The staff’s knowledge and enthusiasm in recommending teas based on individual preferences was commendable, ensuring that each guest finds their perfect cup.

The tiered stand of High Tea delicacies presented before me was a sight to behold. With a mix of both savory and sweet treats, Out There Coffee has struck a perfect balance in their selection. The finger sandwiches were a delightful start, offering an assortment of fillings that ranged from traditional cucumber and cream cheese to more adventurous options like smoked salmon and dill. Each bite was carefully prepared, showcasing fresh ingredients and impeccable attention to detail.

Moving on to the sweet treats, I was treated to an array of delectable pastries and desserts. The scones, served warm and accompanied by clotted cream and jam, were simply divine. Their light and fluffy texture paired wonderfully with the rich, smooth cream and sweet, tangy jam. The assortment of petit fours, cakes, and macarons added an element of elegance and indulgence to the experience, leaving my taste buds dancing with delight.

What sets Out There Coffee apart is not only the quality of their offerings but also their commitment to providing healthier options. Alongside the traditional treats, they incorporate a variety of healthy snacks into the High Tea experience. From fresh fruit skewers to vegetable crudités with flavorful dips, they ensure that guests can indulge in a guilt-free manner. This thoughtful approach makes Out There Coffee an ideal destination for those looking to enjoy a balanced High Tea experience.

The service at Out There Coffee deserves special mention. The staff members were attentive, friendly, and passionate about their craft. Their genuine enthusiasm for the High Tea experience was evident in their interactions, adding to the overall enjoyment of the visit.

In conclusion, Out There Coffee provides a delightful High Tea experience that surpasses expectations. With their delicious locally roasted coffee and espresso as a foundation, they have created a menu of carefully crafted drinks and an array of savory and sweet treats that are sure to satisfy any tea enthusiast. The combination of flavors, attention to detail, and commitment to healthier options make Out There Coffee a standout choice for High Tea in Cape May, NJ. I highly recommend a visit to this charming café to enjoy a delightful afternoon of indulgence and inspiration.

13. Casablanca

709 Columbia Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-4948
Visit Website
Open on Map

Nestled amidst the charming surroundings of Cape May, New Jersey, the Casablanca at 709 Columbia Ave is an exquisite adults-only bed and breakfast that exudes sophistication and elegance. Housed in a beautiful 19th-century home, this hidden gem offers a delightful high tea experience that is sure to captivate your senses.

From the moment you step foot into Casablanca, you are greeted by a sense of timeless charm. The ambiance is inviting, with tasteful decor that pays homage to the property’s rich history. The attention to detail is evident, from the meticulously arranged floral centerpieces to the plush seating that beckons you to relax and unwind.

The high tea experience at Casablanca is a true indulgence for the senses. As you settle into your seat, you are presented with an enticing assortment of teas, carefully selected to cater to a variety of palates. Whether you prefer classic blends or are in the mood for something more adventurous, the knowledgeable staff is on hand to guide you through the extensive tea menu.

Accompanying the teas are an array of delectable treats that are as visually appealing as they are delicious. The delicate finger sandwiches are filled with a medley of flavors, from traditional cucumber and cream cheese to more adventurous combinations that tantalize your taste buds. The freshly baked scones, served warm and accompanied by clotted cream and preserves, are simply divine.

One cannot help but be charmed by the selection of miniature pastries and desserts that grace the tiered trays. Each bite-sized delight is a testament to the skill and artistry of the pastry chefs at Casablanca. From dainty macarons to rich chocolate truffles, every treat is crafted with precision and presented with flair.

What sets Casablanca apart is not just the quality of its offerings, but also the impeccable service provided by the attentive staff. The team at Casablanca is knowledgeable, friendly, and always willing to go the extra mile to ensure that your high tea experience is nothing short of extraordinary. They effortlessly strike the perfect balance between attentiveness and allowing you to savor your moments of relaxation.

As you sip your tea and savor each delectable bite, you can’t help but appreciate the charm of the surrounding area. Casablanca’s proximity to the beach adds an extra touch of enchantment to your experience. After indulging in high tea, taking a leisurely stroll along the shore to bask in the gentle sea breeze is the perfect way to prolong the magic of your visit.

In conclusion, Casablanca at 709 Columbia Ave in Cape May, New Jersey, is a haven for those seeking an exquisite high tea experience. From the elegant setting to the tantalizing treats, every aspect of this adults-only bed and breakfast is designed to transport you to a world of refined luxury. Whether you’re a tea aficionado or simply looking to pamper yourself, a visit to Casablanca is a must.

14. Ostara’s Coffee House

600 Park Blvd 29 -3, West Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 770-7718
Visit Website
Open on Map

Located at 600 Park Blvd 29-3 in West Cape May, NJ, Ostara’s Coffee House is a delightful destination for a high tea experience. Upon entering the establishment, one is immediately struck by its charming ambiance and inviting atmosphere. The interior is tastefully decorated with vintage furniture and cozy seating arrangements, creating a warm and welcoming setting for patrons.

The high tea at Ostara’s Coffee House is truly a treat for the senses. The menu offers a delectable selection of teas from around the world, each served with utmost precision and care. From classic English breakfast tea to exotic herbal infusions, there is something to suit every taste. The staff is knowledgeable and passionate about tea, and they are more than happy to assist in choosing the perfect blend to complement your preferences.

The food served during the high tea is a delightful array of delicate finger sandwiches, freshly baked scones, and an assortment of mouthwatering pastries and cakes. The sandwiches are elegantly presented, with a variety of fillings that cater to both meat lovers and vegetarians alike. The scones are warm, buttery, and perfectly accompanied by clotted cream and homemade jam. The pastries and cakes are a work of art, each bite bursting with flavor and showcasing the skill and creativity of the pastry chef.

The service at Ostara’s Coffee House is impeccable. The staff is attentive, friendly, and well-versed in the art of high tea. They ensure that each guest feels special and attended to, making the experience all the more enjoyable. The attention to detail is evident in every aspect, from the beautifully set tables to the precise pouring of tea. It is clear that the team at Ostara’s Coffee House takes great pride in providing a top-notch high tea experience.

In conclusion, Ostara’s Coffee House in West Cape May, NJ, offers a high tea experience that is second to none. The combination of exceptional teas, exquisite food, attentive service, and charming ambiance make it a must-visit destination for tea enthusiasts and those seeking a delightful afternoon. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a tranquil retreat, Ostara’s Coffee House is the perfect place to enjoy a memorable high tea experience.

15. Hotel Alcott

107-113 Grant St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-5868
Visit Website
Open on Map

Located at 107-113 Grant St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA, Hotel Alcott is a charming and polished Italianate hotel that dates back to 1878. The moment I stepped into this historic establishment, I was transported to a bygone era, with its elegant architecture and old-world charm. The hotel’s attention to detail and commitment to providing a high-end experience truly stood out.

The rooms at Hotel Alcott exuded a sense of luxury and sophistication. Each space was tastefully decorated, combining modern amenities with classic elements. The attention to detail was evident in every aspect, from the plush furnishings to the beautiful artwork adorning the walls. The comfortable beds ensured a restful night’s sleep, while the well-appointed bathrooms added an extra touch of indulgence.

One of the highlights of my stay was the verandas that offered breathtaking views of the surrounding area. It was a pleasure to sip a cup of tea and soak in the serene atmosphere while enjoying the gentle breeze. The verandas provided the perfect setting for relaxation and served as a lovely spot to unwind after a long day of exploring Cape May.

In addition to the wonderful accommodations, Hotel Alcott offered a complimentary continental breakfast. The selection was impressive, featuring a variety of options to suit different tastes. From freshly baked pastries to a wide assortment of fruits, cereals, and yogurts, there was something to satisfy everyone’s cravings. The breakfast was a great way to start the day and provided a delightful culinary experience.

The staff at Hotel Alcott were friendly, attentive, and always willing to go the extra mile to ensure a memorable stay. Their professionalism and genuine hospitality added to the overall ambiance of the hotel. Whether it was recommending local attractions or assisting with any inquiries, they were knowledgeable and eager to help, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere throughout my stay.

Hotel Alcott’s location in Cape May was ideal, situated in close proximity to various points of interest. The hotel’s central position allowed for convenient exploration of the town, including its beautiful beaches, historic sites, and charming boutiques. It was a delight to venture out and discover the local culture and attractions, knowing that I had a comfortable and welcoming haven to return to at the end of the day.

In conclusion, Hotel Alcott is a gem in Cape May, NJ. Its historic charm, luxurious accommodations, stunning verandas, and attentive staff make it an exceptional choice for a high tea experience. Whether you are visiting for a special occasion or simply seeking a tranquil retreat, Hotel Alcott promises a memorable and delightful stay.

16. Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-9090
Visit Website
Open on Map

I recently had the pleasure of experiencing a delightful high tea at Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant, located at 1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA. Nestled in an elegant 1907 beachfront mansion, this romantic eatery offers not only stunning views but also a charming atmosphere that sets the perfect stage for an indulgent afternoon tea.

As I entered the restaurant, I was immediately captivated by the beauty of the surroundings. The historic mansion exudes an air of sophistication and elegance, transporting guests to a bygone era. The tasteful decor and attention to detail added to the overall ambiance, creating a truly enchanting setting.

The high tea experience at Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment I was seated, I was treated with warm hospitality by the attentive staff. They were knowledgeable about the menu and graciously guided me through the tea selection process.

The tea itself was a delight for the senses. The wide variety of teas offered catered to every palate, ensuring that each guest could find their perfect cup. The teas were expertly brewed and presented in charming teapots, allowing the flavors to fully develop and creating a truly satisfying experience.

Accompanying the tea were an array of delectable treats that showcased the chef’s culinary prowess. The tiered tray was filled with mouthwatering sandwiches, scones, pastries, and other sweet treats. Each bite was a revelation of flavors and textures, perfectly complementing the tea and enhancing the overall experience.

One of the highlights of the high tea was the impeccable service. The staff was attentive without being intrusive, ensuring that my tea cup was never empty and accommodating any special requests with ease. Their friendly and professional demeanor further elevated the experience and made me feel truly pampered.

Moreover, the panoramic views from the restaurant added an extra layer of magic to the occasion. The sight of the glistening ocean and the sound of the waves crashing against the shore created a serene backdrop that enhanced the overall sense of tranquility and relaxation.

In conclusion, my high tea experience at Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant was a truly unforgettable one. From the elegant setting and attentive service to the delightful tea and scrumptious treats, every aspect was executed to perfection. I would highly recommend this establishment to anyone seeking a refined and memorable high tea experience.

17. Hemingway’s Steaks & Seafood Restaurant

in the Grand Hotel, 1045 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-5611
Visit Website
Open on Map

Located within the elegant Grand Hotel at 1045 Beach Ave, Cape May, Hemingway’s Steaks & Seafood Restaurant offers a refined and sophisticated dining experience. As soon as you step into the restaurant, you are greeted by a warm ambiance created by the dark woods and the inviting wraparound bar.

Specializing in seafood, steaks, and teas, Hemingway’s Steaks & Seafood lives up to its reputation as a top-notch culinary destination. The menu boasts an impressive array of options, ensuring there is something to satisfy every palate. Whether you have a penchant for perfectly cooked steaks or crave the delicate flavors of freshly caught seafood, this restaurant has you covered.

One cannot help but appreciate the attention to detail in the presentation of the dishes. Each plate is a work of art, meticulously arranged and garnished, creating an enticing visual feast. The flavors are equally impressive, with every bite bursting with freshness and intensity. The chefs at Hemingway’s Steaks & Seafood certainly know how to bring out the best in each ingredient, allowing them to shine.

The service at Hemingway’s is impeccable, with the staff providing attentive and friendly assistance throughout the dining experience. From the moment you are seated until the end of your meal, they strive to ensure your comfort and satisfaction. The servers are knowledgeable about the menu, readily offering recommendations and answering any questions you may have.

The restaurant’s location within the Grand Hotel adds to its charm and allure. The combination of exquisite cuisine, stylish decor, and the hotel’s historic atmosphere creates an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you are celebrating a special occasion or simply seeking a refined setting to indulge in high tea, Hemingway’s Steaks & Seafood is the place to be.

In conclusion, Hemingway’s Steaks & Seafood in Cape May is a destination for those who appreciate fine dining and impeccable service. With its delectable seafood and succulent steaks, and elegant surroundings, this restaurant offers a truly memorable experience. Whether you are a local or a visitor to Cape May, a visit to Hemingway’s Steaks & Seafood is a must for any discerning food enthusiast.

18. McGlade’s On The Pier

722 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-2614
Visit Website
Open on Map

Review: McGlade’s On The Pier – A Delightful High Tea Experience by the Ocean

Tucked away on 722 Beach Ave in the charming Cape May, New Jersey, McGlade’s On The Pier presents itself as a laid-back eatery with an inviting atmosphere. This delightful establishment not only offers classic American eats but also caters to those seeking an exquisite high tea experience. With its ocean-view patio, McGlade’s provides a serene and picturesque setting that enhances the enjoyment of a traditional afternoon tea.

Stepping into McGlade’s, I was greeted by a warm and welcoming ambiance. The interior exudes a casual elegance, effortlessly combining comfort with a touch of sophistication. The friendly staff promptly escorted me to a table on the patio, which allowed me to fully immerse myself in the breathtaking views of the ocean. The setting alone was enough to create an atmosphere of tranquility and relaxation.

As I perused the menu, I was delighted to find an extensive selection of teas from around the world, catering to all tastes and preferences. From aromatic blends to herbal infusions, there was a tea to suit every discerning palate. I opted for a fragrant Earl Grey tea, known for its distinctive floral notes, which arrived promptly in a charming teapot accompanied by a delicate china cup.

The presentation of the high tea was simply impeccable. A three-tiered tray adorned with an array of delectable treats graced the table. The bottom tier featured an assortment of finger sandwiches, each one meticulously crafted with fresh ingredients. The flavors ranged from classic cucumber and cream cheese to smoked salmon with dill. The sandwiches were dainty, yet substantial enough to satisfy any craving.

Moving up the tiers, my attention was drawn to the middle level, which showcased an assortment of freshly baked scones. These golden delights were served warm, with a side of clotted cream and homemade strawberry jam. The scones were delightfully crumbly, and the combination of the rich cream and sweet jam added a burst of flavor that elevated the experience.

Finally, the top tier showcased an assortment of miniature pastries and desserts that were as visually appealing as they were delicious. From delicate éclairs filled with velvety cream to petite fruit tarts bursting with seasonal flavors, each bite was a delight to the senses. The attention to detail in the presentation was evident, and the flavors were perfectly balanced, showcasing the skill and creativity of the pastry chef.

Throughout my high tea experience, the service at McGlade’s was attentive and accommodating. The staff members were knowledgeable about the teas and offerings, providing helpful recommendations and ensuring that my needs were met without being intrusive. Their genuine warmth and enthusiasm further enhanced the overall experience, making me feel like a valued guest.

In conclusion, McGlade’s On The Pier in Cape May, New Jersey, is a hidden gem that offers a delightful high tea experience with a touch of ocean-side charm. From the serene atmosphere to the meticulously crafted sandwiches, scones, and pastries, every aspect of the high tea was executed with precision and care. Whether you are a tea connoisseur or simply looking for a special treat, McGlade’s is sure to exceed your expectations and leave you with cherished memories of a truly memorable afternoon.

19. Love the Cook

404 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA
(609) 884-9292
Visit Website
Open on Map

Love the Cook is a delightful haven for culinary enthusiasts located at 404 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA. Stepping into this charming establishment feels like entering a dream kitchen, equipped with everything one needs to bring their culinary aspirations to life. I recently had the pleasure of experiencing their high tea service, and it was truly a delightful affair.

Upon entering Love the Cook, I was immediately captivated by the inviting ambiance and the warm, friendly staff. The cozy atmosphere set the perfect stage for a memorable high tea experience. The attention to detail in the decor, with its elegant table settings and tasteful floral arrangements, added a touch of sophistication to the overall atmosphere.

The high tea at Love the Cook was a true feast for the senses. The selection of teas offered was impressive, ranging from classic blends to unique and flavorful options. As a tea lover, I appreciated the opportunity to explore different flavors and indulge in a variety of aromatic brews. The teas were expertly brewed and served at the perfect temperature, ensuring a rich and satisfying taste.

Accompanying the teas were an array of delectable treats that showcased the culinary prowess of Love the Cook. The selection of finger sandwiches was a delightful balance of traditional and inventive fillings. From classic cucumber and cream cheese to smoked salmon with dill, each bite was bursting with fresh flavors. The scones, a quintessential element of high tea, were light, fluffy, and perfectly accompanied by clotted cream and preserves.

The highlight of the high tea experience at Love the Cook was the assortment of petite pastries and desserts. Each delicacy was a miniature work of art, meticulously crafted with precision and creativity. From dainty éclairs to intricately decorated macarons, every bite was a delight for both the eyes and the taste buds. The desserts showcased a harmonious balance of flavors and textures, leaving me craving for more.

The service at Love the Cook was impeccable throughout my visit. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about their craft. They took the time to explain each element of the high tea experience, adding an educational touch that further enhanced the overall enjoyment.

Love the Cook has truly mastered the art of high tea, creating an experience that caters to both tea aficionados and food enthusiasts alike. The combination of exquisite teas, delectable treats, and impeccable service makes this establishment a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable and refined high tea experience.

In conclusion, Love the Cook’s high tea is a culinary journey that transcends expectations. From the moment you step through their doors, you are greeted with warmth and immersed in a world of culinary delights. Whether you’re a passionate home cook or simply someone who appreciates fine food and beverages, Love the Cook is the perfect destination to indulge in a memorable high tea experience.