Best High Tea in Cape May, NJ: Top 12!

We’re searching for a sophisticated and refined tea experience all day long in Cape May, NJ, and a fancy High Tea service might be just what we need. This is an opportunity to escape from the monotony of everyday life and to bond with friends or family in a luxurious setting.

Finally, we visited and gathered a list of local spots in Cape May, NJ that offer elegant High Tea services, to help you plan your tea time. It’s important to keep in mind that these tea services often require reservations to be made in advance.

Check out our other local guide on high tea spots around the US.

Tea By the Sea

🌐 Visit Website

All of your loose tea and tea party needs are located in Cape May, NJ. Fine china, children’s sets, and miniatures are available.

The opening hours of Tea By the Sea are as follows: 10:00 AM – 4:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday;

For more information and opening hours, contact Tea By the Sea directly using their phone number (609) 898-4832.

Consumer’s Review: There is an amazing loose leaf tea selection. You can request the staff to bag for you. There are also bags of tea for sale. One of my favorite things is that you can mix and match tea bags so you can try different flavors before committing to a box. If you aren’t from the area, they will ship tea to you if you order online or over the phone. I come here at least once every few months to replenish on tea and get some seasonal offerings.

High Tea in Cape May, NJ

The Harrison

🌐 Visit Website

Some of the rooms at the B&B have claw-foot tubs.

The opening hours of The Harrison are as follows: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday;

For more information and opening hours, contact The Harrison directly using their phone number (609) 884-4948.

Consumer’s Review: I love tea time in the great rooms. Breakfast is enjoyable. The only thing left is parking. You have to park in the street. Sometimes it’s far away. There are two blocks at the most. Still.

Angel of the Sea

🌐 Visit Website

Free breakfast and afternoon tea are offered at the Quaint Accommodations on a 19th century property.

The opening hours of Angel of the Sea are as follows: Open 24 hours on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday;

For more information and opening hours, contact Angel of the Sea directly using their phone number (609) 884-3369.

Consumer’s Review: This is a wonderful place to stay. I’ve visited here many times and it never fails to impress me. The staff is great. They serve a lot of food and drink. This is the best place in Cape May to view the ocean and take a dip in the sand. A very special time of year. Thank you for that!

High Tea in Cape May, NJ

Jardin At The Hugh

🌐 Visit Website

Jardin Restaurant in Cape May is an eco-friendly place to eat. Craig Laban named our prix fixe menu the best at the Shore. We are proud to be vegetarian and vegan.

The opening hours of Jardin At The Hugh are as follows: Closed on Monday, Tuesday, Sunday; 6:30 – 9:00 PM on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday;

For more information and opening hours, contact Jardin At The Hugh directly using their phone number (609) 435-5458.

Consumer’s Review: I had a meal at the Jardin on Wednesday. The food was delicious, innovative, creative, and beautiful. Chef’s creativity is wonderful. It was obvious that our server was a fan of Chef’s works of art, and the service was great. If you have the experience, please recommend it.

Magic Brain Cafe

🌐 Visit Website

There are espresso drinks, tea, sweets, and baked goods in the coffee shop.

The opening hours of Magic Brain Cafe are as follows: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday;

Consumer’s Review: Coffee and pastries are the best in Cape May. Awesome, friendly, helpful baristas that make your day better. The cinnamon bun croissants are great as well. The vibe is great too!

High Tea in Cape May, NJ

Coffee Tyme At The Beach

🌐 Visit Website

Hot & iced coffee, baked goods, and breakfast sandwiches can be found at the Quaint counter-serve.

The opening hours of Coffee Tyme At The Beach are as follows: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday;

For more information and opening hours, contact Coffee Tyme At The Beach directly using their phone number (609) 435-5647.

Consumer’s Review: I loved this place! Coffee and tea were very good. The bagels were delicious! The place has coffee. For home, I bought different flavors of coffee beans. If you’re in town, please visit it.

Coffee Tyme At The Mall

🌐 Visit Website

The #1 coffee shop is in Cape May. The Best Coffee of Cape May was voted on three times. Breakfast sandwiches and baked goods are also available.

The opening hours of Coffee Tyme At The Mall are as follows: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday;

For more information and opening hours, contact Coffee Tyme At The Mall directly using their phone number (609) 435-5647.

Consumer’s Review: Customer service and coffee are very good. Will definitely return.

High Tea in Cape May, NJ

Tommy’s Folly

🌐 Visit Website

The opening hours of Tommy’s Folly are as follows: 6:30 AM – 5:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday; 6:30 AM – 6:00 PM on Friday, Saturday;

For more information and opening hours, contact Tommy’s Folly directly using their phone number (609) 884-6566.

Consumer’s Review: Excellent coffee. The chocolate chip cookies are also favorites.

Out There Coffee

🌐 Visit Website

Coffee and espresso are available at the Out There Coffee shop. The drinks are carefully crafted. Providing healthy snacks and treats. Encouraging others to get out there and do what makes them happy!

The opening hours of Out There Coffee are as follows: 7:00 AM – 1:00 PM on Monday; Closed on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday; 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM on Friday, Saturday, Sunday;

Consumer’s Review: Good coffee and hot chocolate. Would order to go from there again.

High Tea in Cape May, NJ

Casablanca

🌐 Visit Website

The B&B is in a 19th-century home and is close to the beach.

The opening hours of Casablanca are as follows: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday;

For more information and opening hours, contact Casablanca directly using their phone number (609) 884-4948.

Consumer’s Review: My husband and I love this place so much. Every year, we come for our anniversary and never leave disappointed. They are very professional and detail oriented. You are welcomed when you walk in. Casablanca is clean and beautiful. The food is amazing. We recommend this place to everyone.

Ostara’s Coffee House

🌐 Visit Website

The opening hours of Ostara’s Coffee House are as follows: 7:30 AM – 2:00 PM on Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday; Closed on Tuesday;

For more information and opening hours, contact Ostara’s Coffee House directly using their phone number (609) 770-7718.

Consumer’s Review: The muffins are exceptional. There is a lot of space with 4 tables inside and a few outside.

High Tea in Cape May, NJ

Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

🌐 Visit Website

The 1907 beachfront mansion is where this romantic eatery is located.

The opening hours of Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant are as follows: 5:00 – 8:00 PM on Monday, Thursday, Sunday; Closed on Tuesday, Wednesday; 5:00 – 8:30 PM on Friday, Saturday;

For more information and opening hours, contact Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant directly using their phone number (609) 884-9090.

Consumer’s Review: On New Years Day, I went here. It is the best restaurant in Cape May. It is amazing. Service is excellent. Cuisine is great. Oysters were as fresh as you can get. Crab cakes were very good. I live in the state of Maryland.